Back

Geofence Warrants After Chatrie: The 2026 Supreme Court Ruling and the Third-Party Doctrine

Hand holding a smartphone showing a detailed city street map outdoors beside a dark metal railing

Last updated: 18 November 2026. Case details come from the Supreme Court’s opinion and docket in Chatrie v. United States (No. 25-112), the Fifth Circuit’s opinion in United States v. Smith, Google’s own announcement, the Utah Code, UK legislation and the Court of Justice of the EU. Post-Chatrie rulings are taken from a Paul, Weiss client memo of 16 October 2026.

Short answer: On 29 June 2026 the Supreme Court held in Chatrie v. United States, by 6 to 3, that getting a person’s Google Location History through a geofence warrant is a Fourth Amendment search, and refused to apply the third-party doctrine. It did not ban geofence warrants. The Fourth Circuit must now decide whether the warrant was valid, with argument set for 9 December 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Chatrie extends Carpenter v. United States (2018): people have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their phone’s location records, even for a two-hour window and even when they switched the feature on themselves.
  • The Court did not decide whether the three-step geofence warrant had enough probable cause and particularity. It sent that question, and possibly good faith, back to the Fourth Circuit.
  • The Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi) already treats geofence warrants as categorically unconstitutional general warrants under United States v. Smith (2024).
  • Google moved Location History onto users’ devices in July 2025 and says it can no longer answer geofence warrants for that data, but the ruling is framed around cell-phone location records generally, not Google alone.

What is a geofence warrant?

A normal warrant starts with a suspect and asks where the evidence is. A geofence warrant works the other way round. Police draw a virtual fence around a crime scene for a set period and ask a company to say which devices were inside it. Courts often call them reverse warrants.

In Chatrie, the officers proposed a circle with a radius of 150 metres around a credit union in Midlothian, Virginia, which was robbed on 20 May 2019. Google answered in three steps, as the Supreme Court’s opinion describes:

  1. Step one. Google produced anonymised location data for every account inside the fence from 30 minutes before to 30 minutes after the robbery.
  2. Step two. Officers picked devices from that list and Google gave more anonymised data covering a two-hour period, inside and outside the fence.
  3. Step three. Officers narrowed the list again and Google disclosed names, email addresses and phone numbers. Three users were identified, including Okello Chatrie.

Google was the main target because of the size of its Location History store. The Fifth Circuit noted that by 2021 geofence warrants made up more than 25% of all warrant requests Google received in the United States. The Supreme Court added that Apple, Lyft, Snapchat and Uber have also received them, but that Google was the only company known to respond.

What did the Supreme Court decide in Chatrie v. United States?

The case reached the Court after the lower courts disagreed about almost everything except the result. The table sets out the path, using the Supreme Court docket and the opinion.

StageDateWhat happened
District court (E.D. Va.)2022Found a search and a defective warrant, but refused to suppress under the good-faith exception. Chatrie entered a conditional guilty plea.
Fourth Circuit panel2024Affirmed on a different ground: no search, because Chatrie had shared his location with Google.
Fourth Circuit en banc30 April 2025Affirmed in a one-sentence per curiam. The judges split 7 to 7 on whether there was a search.
Certiorari granted16 January 2026Limited to the first question: whether executing the warrant violated the Fourth Amendment.
Oral argument27 April 2026Adam Unikowsky for Chatrie; Deputy Solicitor General Eric Feigin for the United States.
Decision29 June 2026Judgment vacated and case remanded, 6 to 3. Opinion by Justice Kagan.
Fourth Circuit on remandArgument 9 December 2026Pending as of 18 November 2026.

Justice Kagan wrote for herself, Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Sotomayor, Kavanaugh and Jackson. The opinion holds that a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy in records of his cell phone’s location, so obtaining Chatrie’s Location History was a search. The government argued that two hours of data was too little to matter. The Court replied: “It does not matter if the time period scrutinized was only two hours.”

The separate opinions show how unsettled the area still is. Justice Jackson, joined by Justice Sotomayor, would have held the warrant invalid because steps two and three let officers obtain sensitive data without a magistrate checking probable cause. Justice Gorsuch concurred only in the judgment, treating the data as Chatrie’s property rather than applying the privacy-expectation test. Justice Alito, joined in part by Justices Thomas and Barrett, dissented and argued that the good-faith exception would decide the case anyway. Justice Barrett wrote separately to say Chatrie had no reasonable expectation of privacy in data he chose to give Google. For more on her votes that term, see our profile of Justice Barrett’s swing votes in the 2025-26 term.

How does Chatrie change the third-party doctrine?

The third-party doctrine comes from two 1970s cases. In United States v. Miller (1976), a bank customer had no reasonable expectation of privacy in cheques and deposit slips held by his bank. In Smith v. Maryland (1979), a telephone subscriber had none in the numbers he dialled, because he had “voluntarily conveyed” them to the phone company. The idea is that what you hand to a business, you risk the business handing to the government.

In Carpenter v. United States, decided 5 to 4 in 2018, the Court refused to apply that idea to seven days of cell-site location records held by wireless carriers. Phone location data, it said, is far more revealing than bank records and is “not truly shared” in any normal sense, because carrying a phone is part of modern life.

The government tried to distinguish Chatrie on the second point. Unlike cell-site data, Location History is off by default and the user has to switch it on. The majority rejected that argument. It found that Google’s opt-in prompts did not clearly explain how much data was collected, and that exposing data to Google is simply “the automatic price of conventional cell-phone usage”. So, it held, “just as the third-party doctrine did not apply in Carpenter, it does not apply here.”

Three practical points follow:

  • Smith and Miller still stand. The Court did not overrule them; it limited their reach. Our explainer on stare decisis covers how the Court narrows precedent without overruling it.
  • Clicking “I agree” is not consent to government access. The majority rejected an app-by-app, setting-by-setting approach, which matters for any cloud service.
  • Short windows are covered. Carpenter involved seven days. Chatrie involved two hours. The dissent complained that the majority dropped Carpenter’s seven-day line, and it is right that there is now no minimum.
Front of the US Supreme Court building with its marble columns and steps under a blue sky
The Supreme Court held on 29 June 2026 that obtaining Location History is a search, then sent the warrant question back to the Fourth Circuit. Photo: Mark Stebnicki / Pexels

Are geofence warrants legal after Chatrie?

Yes, in most of the country, if they satisfy the Fourth Amendment. Chatrie decided that a warrant is needed. It did not decide what a valid geofence warrant looks like. The Court left the Fourth Circuit to decide “whether, given the warrant issued, the search was reasonable”, meaning whether each of the three steps rested on probable cause and described what could be searched with particularity. A footnote also preserves warrantless geofence searches in true emergencies.

The Fifth Circuit went further two years earlier. In United States v. Smith, decided on 9 August 2024 in a Mississippi post office robbery case, it held “that geofence warrants are general warrants categorically prohibited by the Fourth Amendment”, because they never name a specific user. It still let the evidence in under the good-faith exception, as the officers had relied on a warrant in 2018 when the technique was new. Smith binds federal courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.

Early rulings since Chatrie point towards closer scrutiny of probable cause. According to a Paul, Weiss memo of 16 October 2026:

  • In State v. Hobbs (2 October 2026), New Jersey’s Appellate Division held that the fact that “cell phones are common” does not by itself establish probable cause for a geofence warrant.
  • A federal judge in the Southern District of Mississippi treated a tower dump as a search on 5 August 2026.
  • The Fourth Circuit treated police use of a cell-site simulator as a search in Andrews v. Baltimore City Police Department (24 September 2026).

The memo also reports that the Fourth Circuit has set argument in Chatrie’s remand for 9 December 2026. Until it rules, the scope of a lawful geofence warrant remains open in the Fourth Circuit and most other circuits.

Did Google’s Location History change end geofence warrants?

Largely, for Google. In a post on 12 December 2023, Google said Timeline data powered by Location History would soon be saved on users’ devices, with encrypted cloud backup that “no one can read”, including Google. The Supreme Court’s opinion records that the change took effect in July 2025 and that Google now says it “is no longer capable of responding to geofence warrants that seek Location History data.”

That does not make Chatrie academic. Justice Alito argued the case was a poor vehicle for exactly that reason, and Justice Barrett disagreed. The holding is about location records generally, so it applies to any provider that still stores them on its servers. In Smith, the government told the Fifth Circuit that it may seek geofence warrants from sources other than Google. Our guide to whether police can track your phone without a warrant covers tower dumps, real-time pings and data bought from brokers.

Do any states regulate geofence warrants?

Some do by statute. Utah’s Code section 77-23f-102, enacted in 2023, generally bars police from obtaining reverse-location information without a warrant. The application must include a map of the geofence and a specified time period, and the court must require that all device data be anonymised before release. Investigations must involve a felony, certain serious misdemeanours or an imminent threat to public safety.

State courts can also apply their own constitutions, which may protect more than the Fourth Amendment does. Several state bills were introduced in recent years; we have only listed the Utah law because it is the one we could confirm in force.

How do the UK and EU handle police requests for location data?

There is no direct equivalent to Chatrie because neither system relies on a third-party doctrine. In the UK, police obtain communications data, which can include where a device was, under Part 3 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. Most requests need authorisation from the Investigatory Powers Commissioner under section 60A, who must find the request necessary for a specific investigation or operation and proportionate.

In the EU, the Court of Justice held in Prokuratuur (Case C-746/18, 2 March 2021) that access to traffic or location data revealing a person’s private life must be limited to serious crime or serious threats to public security, whatever the length of the period covered, and cannot be authorised by the public prosecutor running the investigation.

What should lawyers do with Chatrie now?

  • Defence counsel: identify every location record in discovery, ask how it was obtained and challenge probable cause and particularity at each step of any multi-step warrant. Raise it early; our guide to what happens at an arraignment explains the timing of pretrial motions.
  • Prosecutors: expect courts to read geofence applications closely. In Smith, good faith rested on the technique being new in 2018; after Smith and Chatrie, that argument is harder to make for a fresh warrant, so applications should explain why the fence, the time window and each later step are justified.
  • Everyone: watch the Fourth Circuit’s remand decision and any government appeal of the Mississippi tower dump ruling. These are the likeliest routes for the next Supreme Court case.

Chatrie now sits in the line of privacy cases that runs from Katz v. United States (1967) through Carpenter, both of which appear in our list of landmark Supreme Court cases.

Frequently asked questions

Did the Supreme Court ban geofence warrants?

No. In Chatrie v. United States (29 June 2026) the Court held that obtaining Google Location History is a search, so police need a valid warrant. It left open whether the three-step geofence warrant used in that case met the probable cause and particularity rules.

What was the vote in Chatrie v. United States?

Six to three. Justice Kagan wrote for Chief Justice Roberts and Justices Sotomayor, Kavanaugh and Jackson, and Justice Gorsuch concurred in the judgment. Justices Alito, Thomas and Barrett dissented.

What is the third-party doctrine?

It is the rule from Smith v. Maryland and United States v. Miller that a person has no reasonable expectation of privacy in information voluntarily given to a business. Carpenter refused to apply it to cell-site records, and Chatrie refused to apply it to Location History.

Are geofence warrants unconstitutional in Texas?

In federal courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, yes. The Fifth Circuit held in United States v. Smith (9 August 2024) that geofence warrants are general warrants categorically prohibited by the Fourth Amendment, although it applied the good-faith exception in that case.

Can Google still respond to geofence warrants?

Google says it cannot for Location History. It moved that data onto users’ devices in July 2025, according to the Supreme Court’s opinion, and told the Court it is no longer capable of responding to geofence warrants for it.

What happens next in the Chatrie case?

The Fourth Circuit must decide whether the warrant was supported by probable cause and described with particularity, and may then consider good faith. Argument on remand is set for 9 December 2026, according to a Paul, Weiss memo.

This article is general information about US, UK and EU law as of 18 November 2026, not legal advice. If you are charged with a crime or advising someone who is, speak to a lawyer licensed in the relevant jurisdiction.

LEGAL DESIRE NEWSLETTER

Where the legal industry reads first.

Enjoyed this article? Get the biggest legal industry updates, deals, appointments, insights and expert interviews in your inbox, free.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

From Legal Desire

Is your firm the one being cited, or the one being skipped?

We ran the test. On several everyday legal questions, software companies are answering and law firms are not. We help firms fix that, and we build the technology behind the practice.

Lawyers and firms: get featured on Legal Desire

Share your deals, lateral moves, firm news and insights with 1M+ monthly readers: founders, law firm partners, general counsel and practising lawyers across the US, UK, EU and GCC.

Get featuredSubmit a press release
Legal Desire Press
https://legaldesire.com/about-us/
Our editorial team that covers judgments, deals, law firm updates, careers and policy across the globe. Coverage is editorially independent; sponsored posts are labeled Partner Content.