
Last updated: 24 October 2026. This article reports on a court order and is not legal advice.
Short answer: On 14 October 2026, Judge Douglas R. Cole of the US District Court for the Southern District of Ohio refused to grant Amazon summary judgment on direct and vicarious copyright infringement claims brought by Weekend Warrior Clothing, a small T-shirt company, over designs sold through Amazon’s Merch on Demand print-on-demand service. The court threw out the contributory infringement claim, but the core of the case is now headed towards trial.
Key takeaways
- Amazon must face direct and vicarious infringement claims over T-shirts made and sold through Merch on Demand. Contributory infringement was dismissed.
- The court found that Amazon sets the price, names itself as seller, manufactures and ships the products, which a jury could treat as volitional conduct rather than passive hosting.
- Judge Cole described Amazon’s handling of Weekend Warrior’s infringement notices as “dismal” and said a jury could find willful blindness, keeping enhanced statutory damages on the table.
- Amazon’s DMCA safe harbour defence did not get summary judgment because a jury could find notices were left to “fall into a vacuum.”
What is the case about?
Weekend Warrior Clothing, LLC was set up in 2018 by brothers Tim and Daniel Whelan. It sells humorous apparel under the brand USA Drinking Team on its own website, not on Amazon. It holds 48 copyright registrations relevant to the case, with Daniel named as author on each.
Merch on Demand lets third-party “content creators” upload designs. Amazon then generates product images, lists the items at a price it chooses, identifies itself as the seller, prints and ships the products, collects payment and pays the creator a “royalty.” Weekend Warrior says users uploaded copies of its designs and that Amazon sold infringing products. Rather than chase individual uploaders, it sued Amazon for direct, contributory and vicarious infringement (Weekend Warrior Clothing, LLC v. Amazon.com Services, LLC, No. 1:23-cv-752, S.D. Ohio). The case is represented by Watstein Terepka LLP, led by George Laiolo, Matthew Venezia and Daniel Contreras.
What did the court decide?
| Issue | Ruling |
|---|---|
| Weekend Warrior’s motion for summary judgment | Denied, because there is a genuine dispute over whether its copyrights are valid |
| Direct infringement | Amazon’s motion denied |
| Vicarious infringement | Amazon’s motion denied |
| Contributory infringement | Granted for Amazon |
| DMCA safe harbour | Amazon’s motion denied |
| Willfulness (enhanced statutory damages) | Amazon’s motion denied |
| Ameri-CAN v2 and Down Goes Liver designs | Claims dismissed without prejudice |
Why could Amazon be a direct infringer?
Direct infringement usually requires volitional conduct by the defendant, not just providing a tool that someone else misuses. Amazon argued it was the modern equivalent of a copy shop with a public photocopier. Judge Cole turned that analogy around. Imagine, he wrote, a shop that keeps an electronic copy of what a customer copies, invites others to order reproductions, puts the pictures in its window with a “buy these here” sign at a price it alone sets, and pays a royalty to the original customer. That shop “is no longer passively providing a machine; it is taking a hands-on approach to moving product.”
The court contrasted Merch on Demand with platforms where users control listings and prices, and relied on decisions involving Redbubble, where courts have looked at who controls manufacture, sale and shipping.
What did the court say about Amazon’s notice handling?
This is the passage brand owners will quote. Weekend Warrior sent Notices of Claimed Infringement about what it described as pixel-for-pixel copies. The court said it would not “belabor the record about Amazon’s response to those NOCIs beyond noting that it could best be described as dismal.” Amazon’s automated process flagged Tim Whelan’s reports as fraudulent and sent his later emails to the trash, even though he had supplied the information Amazon asked for.
The court accepted that Amazon needs a filter for bad-faith reports, but said that is “the cost of operating a service where anyone can upload designs.” On willfulness it went further: Amazon “may wish to deny actual or constructive knowledge because it did not review these reports. But that was by its own design.” A reasonable jury, it held, could find willful blindness.
What does Weekend Warrior’s lawyer say?
George Laiolo, a partner at Watstein Terepka and one of Weekend Warrior’s lead attorneys, told Legal Desire:
“Amazon sold thousands of knockoffs of Weekend Warrior’s original designs. The company’s conduct led to massive losses for two brothers, Tim and Daniel Whelan, who quit their corporate jobs to start a small business doing what they love. Besides submitting proposed knockoff designs to Merch on Demand, Amazon, not its users, but Amazon itself, controls the entire chain. It has the ability to review every design submitted, and displays, offers, manufactures, sells, and ships everything on Merch. For the Whelans’ designs specifically, Amazon could have stopped its infringement years before Weekend Warrior sued, but it chose to look the other way.”
“This problem plagues the entire print-on-demand industry. Companies like Amazon know their shops are filled with knockoffs, but they also know those knockoffs make a lot of money. So they make it extremely difficult for independent brands to police their IP, hoping that they’ll give up and just accept mass counterfeiting as a cost of doing business. The Whelans refused to give up. They look forward to proving their case in what will be the first copyright jury trial Amazon has ever faced.”
Whether this would in fact be Amazon’s first copyright jury trial is the firm’s description; Legal Desire has not independently verified it.
What happens next?
The case moves towards trial on direct and vicarious infringement. Validity of Weekend Warrior’s copyrights is still disputed, including whether 21 designs are derivative of material Daniel drew on as reference. Weekend Warrior has conceded it cannot claim statutory damages for 22 designs registered too late. The court allowed two later-registered designs to be added. No trial date had been reported at the time of writing.
Frequently asked questions
Is Amazon liable for print-on-demand infringement?
Not yet. The court only held that a jury could find Amazon liable as a direct or vicarious infringer. Liability will be decided at trial, and the validity of the copyrights is still in dispute.
Why was contributory infringement dismissed?
The court agreed with Amazon that, on the way Merch on Demand works, Amazon is either a direct infringer or a vicarious one, and the contributory theory did not fit the facts.
What does “willful blindness” mean here?
Deliberately avoiding knowledge of infringement. The court said a jury could find that Amazon built a system that discarded the reports that would have told it about the copies.
Did the DMCA protect Amazon?
Not at this stage. A jury could find Amazon did not reasonably implement a repeat-infringer policy because notices went unheeded.
Who represents Weekend Warrior?
Watstein Terepka LLP, led by George Laiolo, Matthew Venezia and Daniel Contreras.
Read the opinion and order on CourtListener.
Featured image: George Laiolo, partner at Watstein Terepka LLP and one of Weekend Warrior’s lead attorneys. Photo courtesy of Watstein Terepka LLP.
Where the legal industry reads first.
Enjoyed this article? Get the biggest legal industry updates, deals, appointments, insights and expert interviews in your inbox, free.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.From Legal Desire
Is your firm the one being cited, or the one being skipped?
We ran the test. On several everyday legal questions, software companies are answering and law firms are not. We help firms fix that, and we build the technology behind the practice.
Lawyers and firms: get featured on Legal Desire
Share your deals, lateral moves, firm news and insights with 1M+ monthly readers: founders, law firm partners, general counsel and practising lawyers across the US, UK, EU and GCC.
Get featuredSubmit a press release

