
Australian law firms spent 2024 experimenting with generative AI and 2025 discovering that the courts had opinions about it. By late 2026 the picture is clearer. The Supreme Court of New South Wales has a binding practice note, the Federal Court has published its own, and the profession’s regulators in three states have set out what they expect from any lawyer who uses these tools.
For firms outside Australia, the interesting part is not that judges are worried about invented citations. Courts everywhere share that concern. What stands out is how specific the Australian rules have become about data, evidence and verification, and how directly those rules now feed into the question every managing partner is asking: which product can we safely put in front of our lawyers and our clients’ files?
This article walks through the main instruments, explains what each one actually requires, and translates those requirements into the questions a firm should ask a vendor before signing. It draws only on the published texts of the courts and regulators concerned, so the details can be checked against the original documents rather than taken from commentary or marketing material.
The NSW practice note set the template
Practice Note SC Gen 23, on the use of generative artificial intelligence, was first issued by the Supreme Court of New South Wales in November 2024, amended in January 2025 and commenced on 3 February 2025. It applies to all proceedings in that court, and it moves beyond general warnings into concrete rules that practitioners must follow when preparing documents.
Its most quoted provision deals with evidence. Generative AI must not be used to generate the content of affidavits, witness statements or character references, and it must not be used to alter, embellish, strengthen or dilute a witness’s evidence. Those documents must now carry a disclosure that AI was not used in that way, although purely preparatory work on a draft remains permitted.
Written submissions are treated differently. Where AI has helped prepare them, the author must verify in the body of the document that every citation and authority exists, is accurate and is relevant to the proceedings. The note adds a detail many firms overlooked at first: that verification must not be carried out solely by using another generative AI tool.
Confidential material is where tools are won or lost
The provision with the largest commercial impact is paragraph 9A. Material subject to suppression orders, documents produced on subpoena and information covered by the implied undertaking must not be entered into a generative AI program unless the practitioner is satisfied of three things about the platform being used for the work.
The information must stay within the controlled environment of that platform, with confidentiality restrictions binding on the supplier so the data is not made publicly available. It must be used only in connection with that proceeding. And it must not be used to train the program or any large language model. A free consumer chatbot cannot give a firm that assurance in writing.
That single paragraph changes how procurement works. The questions about training on customer data, where content is held and who can access it stop being preferences and become conditions for using the tool on litigation files. Firms that cannot obtain clear contractual answers on those points are, in practice, limited to using AI on material that carries no such restrictions.
Federal and regulatory expectations line up
The Federal Court of Australia took longer. After a statement by the Chief Justice on 28 March 2025 and a notice to the profession on 29 April 2025 inviting submissions, the Court published its Generative Artificial Intelligence Practice Note on 16 April 2026, after a period of internal and external consultation.
According to the Court’s notice, the practice note identifies areas requiring particular caution, including pleadings, submissions, evidence and dealings with confidential or protected information, and explains when disclosure of AI use may be required. It also stresses that use must remain consistent with existing legal and professional obligations, which places accountability for anything filed squarely with the parties.
The regulators had already moved in the same direction. On 6 December 2024 the Victorian Legal Services Board and Commissioner, the Law Society of NSW and the Legal Practice Board of Western Australia issued a joint statement. It reminds lawyers that accuracy is their duty and not the program’s, suggests limiting AI to lower risk tasks, and asks for transparency with clients and courts where required.
What happens when verification fails
The consequences are no longer hypothetical. In August 2025 the Victorian Legal Services Board varied the practising certificate of a solicitor who had tendered to the Federal Circuit and Family Court a list and summary of authorities generated with AI, which turned out to contain inaccurate citations. The referral came from the court’s judgment in Dayal [2024] FedCFamC2F 1166.
Under the variation, which the Board announced in September 2025, he can no longer practise as a principal lawyer, handle trust money or operate his own practice. He may work only as an employee solicitor, under supervision for two years, with quarterly reports to the Board during that period. For a sole practitioner, conditions of that kind effectively end the business as it was run before.
The lesson for firms is less about the individual and more about systems. A tool that produces plausible but unchecked citations creates a risk that the practitioner carries personally. Products that link every proposition to a paragraph in a reported judgment, or that make checking quick, reduce that exposure in a way that generic assistants simply do not.
Turning the rules into a buying checklist
Read together, these instruments give firms a practical shortlist of questions. Does the vendor contractually exclude training on client content? Where is the data processed and stored? Can the firm prove what the tool was used for if a court asks? Does the product make citations easy to trace back to a primary source rather than another summary?
Privacy law adds a further layer. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner published guidance on commercially available AI products on 21 October 2024. It says privacy obligations apply both to personal information entered into an AI system and to output that contains personal information, and it expects organisations to carry out due diligence before adopting a product.
Firms comparing products against these tests will find the market already sorted into broad groups, from research platforms built on local case law to the assistants inside practice management software. A current overview of AI tools for Australian lawyers is a reasonable place to see how the main options handle data hosting and citations before arranging demonstrations.
A model other jurisdictions are watching
Australia is not the only jurisdiction writing rules for AI in litigation, but its rules are unusually concrete. Instead of telling lawyers to be careful, the NSW rules say which documents are off limits, what must be disclosed and what a platform has to guarantee before restricted material goes anywhere near it. That precision makes the rules easier to follow and easier to enforce.
For firms elsewhere, the Australian experience suggests a sensible order of work. Settle the confidentiality conditions first, because they decide which tools are even eligible. Then decide who verifies what, and how that verification is recorded. Only after that does it make sense to compare features, prices and the promises in each vendor’s demonstration.
The courts have been clear that responsibility does not move to the software. What has changed is that the question of which tool a firm uses is now part of that responsibility. A procurement decision made casually in 2024 can become a professional conduct question in 2026, and Australian practitioners have learned that faster than most.
Where the legal industry reads first.
Enjoyed this article? Get the biggest legal industry updates, deals, appointments, insights and expert interviews in your inbox, free.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.From Legal Desire
Is your firm the one being cited, or the one being skipped?
We ran the test. On several everyday legal questions, software companies are answering and law firms are not. We help firms fix that, and we build the technology behind the practice.
Lawyers and firms: get featured on Legal Desire
Share your deals, lateral moves, firm news and insights with 1M+ monthly readers: founders, law firm partners, general counsel and practising lawyers across the US, UK, EU and GCC.
Get featuredSubmit a press release

