Back

After Nearly 30 Years, Investigators Found a Name For The Man Beside I-65 in Atmore

Atmore

The skeletal remains, located near an Alabama interstate, have gone unidentified for nearly 30 years. The man is the same one who was reported missing in Georgia, Jimmy Monroe Pitts, the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office said this week. Investigators attribute the identification to a mix of newer DNA technology and one investigator’s perseverance.

On May 18, 1997, the remains were located in the southern Alabama County of Escambia near Interstate 65 in Atmore. Pitts was born on Feb. 21, 1953, making him 44 years old at the time of his discovery 44 years. He would now be 73. But for years, no one could say who he was. The remains were in such condition at the time, and the limits of forensic science meant investigators were unable to identify the victim, and the case became an unidentified John Doe. Things began to change in 2020. Crime scene investigator Lindsey Miles took up a new search to find the man, contacting forensic agencies in an attempt to get advanced DNA testing performed. The first half was dismal. Several attempts were made, but none were successful, the sheriff’s office said, a common occurrence with long-old exposed remains. The vast majority of old bone contains little or no usable DNA, and what DNA there is often damaged.

This breakthrough occurred in 2025, when DNA Labs International got the remains and sequenced the DNA. That allowed forensic genetic genealogy to become a reality. The method has revolutionised the potential of cold case teams, and the core concept is quite straightforward. A laboratory creates a comprehensive DNA profile from the remains, and genealogists match the profile with those that individuals have given to genealogical databases. A match to a distant cousin doesn’t indicate any name. Researchers then construct pedigrees from public records down to the point where they can identify a person that matches the age, sex and circumstances of the unknown person.

Moxxy Forensic Investigations did just that in August of 2026, and found Pitts to be a possible match. But first, the lead had to be tested before the sheriff’s office could tell the public. Escambia County Sheriff’s investigators went to Georgia, where Pitts had been reported missing, to collect a reference DNA sample from his sister. The DNA of her sample was then compared with the DNA of the remains by DNA Labs International. The outcome of the procedure enabled investigators to obtain scientific evidence to confirm his identity.

That last step is very important. A genealogy match is a good lead, but until a close relative’s DNA validates a genealogy match, it is a hypothesis. Sibling samples are especially valuable since siblings share a significant amount of their DNA, making a comparison easy to make. In this instance, it did, and it made a candidate’s name definite.

Sheriff Heath Jackson discussed the case as it relates to reality. “It’s a reminder that investigative work doesn’t always yield immediate answers and that after almost 30 years, Pitts’ name is back,” he said. He also thanked the efforts of his staff in staying upbeat and expressed his gratitude to all those who helped identify. The agency has stated the probe has been completed, and there is no evidence of foul play.

There is a need to be clear about what this announcement means and does not mean. The reports I could find don’t have any explanations for how Pitts ended up near an Alabama interstate, when exactly he was missing from Georgia, or how long Pitts’ remains had been there before they were discovered. The questions might never have a public resolution without foul play suspected. What the authorities have made known is who he was and that his family can at last be told. That’s not something to take lightly for family members who didn’t know for decades.

The case also demonstrates the change in the chances of helping solve old cases. In 1997, remains were discovered that would not have been recognizable with the tools available at the time, and in 2020, multiple tests were unsuccessful. Better laboratory techniques, a specialized genealogy team and an investigator who can persevere for five years. There are numerous agencies that have unclaimed remains from the ’90s and on, and every success such as these serves to remind other agencies and families to check their records.

There’s a human aspect to this as well. In some ways, a John Doe case is a man without a story. There’s really no way to grieve for him and no way for his family to put away what they’ve been carrying. Thirty years later, when someone’s name is called back, he is brought back to the community that knew him. That’s been the case this week in Atmore, and a long question has been answered for one Georgia family.

Resources:

LEGAL DESIRE NEWSLETTER

Where the legal industry reads first.

Enjoyed this article? Get the biggest legal industry updates, deals, appointments, insights and expert interviews in your inbox, free.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

From Legal Desire

Is your firm the one being cited, or the one being skipped?

We ran the test. On several everyday legal questions, software companies are answering and law firms are not. We help firms fix that, and we build the technology behind the practice.

Lawyers and firms: get featured on Legal Desire

Share your deals, lateral moves, firm news and insights with 1M+ monthly readers: founders, law firm partners, general counsel and practising lawyers across the US, UK, EU and GCC.

Get featuredSubmit a press release
Dopathi Nithin
Dopathi Nithin is a postgraduate student currently pursuing M.Sc Forensic Science at Guru Ghasidas Vishwavidyalaya, Bilaspur. He has a Bachelor's degree in Forensic Science and has undertaken internships at Forensic Services India, Questioned Document Division and also at State Forensic Science Laboratory (SFSL), Raipur to have hands-on experience in handling of evidence, forensic document examination and laboratory analysis. He is interested in forensic biology, toxicology, questioned documents, crime scene investigation and emerging forensic technologies. As part of Legal Desire Forensics, he is dedicated to advancing the correct and research-based and accessible knowledge of the field of forensic science.