The Bombay High Court on Tuesday has declined to grant any interim relief to Bollywood actors Ranveer Singh and Arjun Kapoor over an FIR filed against them and other film personalities for using “obscene” and “abusive” language during a comedy event ‘AIB Knockout’ in 2015.
This decision was given by a bench of Justices R.M. Savant and Sarang Kotwal who directed the actors’ lawyer to seek the assent of the Acting Chief Justice V.K. Tahilramani’s court for the matter to be heard along with two other related pleas.
One of these two pleas were filed by comedian Rohan Joshi of AIB, a comedy collective, seeking that a related FIR against him be quashed.
The other plea was a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by a law teacher from the city. The PIL pleads for action against the organizers and participants of the show, and also urges the HC to direct the state authorities to issue guidelines to monitor such programmes on YouTube and similar video networks.
The actors, meanwhile, have requested the court to direct, by way of an interim relief, the Pune and Mumbai police to refrain from taking any coercive action against them.
The bench giving the above order however said that it will consider the prayer once all the three pleas were tagged together and assigned for further hearing by the Acting CJI’s court.
On December, 20, 2014, Ranveer Singh and Arjun Kapoor, along with eight other celebrities, including Karan Johar, Deepika Padukone and members of the AIB team had performed at a charity event in Worli. Later a video of the event was subsequently uploaded on YouTube which became viral.
In February, 2015, one Sateesh Daundkar filed a complaint with the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate of the Girgaon court here, claiming the show was “vulgar, obscene and pornographic”.The court then ordered that an FIR be registered against all the ten people.
Soon after the lodging of first FIR another FIR was registered against all the ten persons in Pune following a complaint by a local alleging obscenity during the event.
Singh and Kapoor had approached the Mumbai HC earlier this year after they had received summons from the Pune police, directing them to visit the police station for questioning and recording their statements.
They have contended in their plea that the FIRs against them bore an ulterior motive and were filed with “mischievous” and malafide intent, and sought their quashing.
In 2015, another bench of the HC had granted interim relief to Padukone, Johar, and the AIB members and directed both the Mumbai and Pune police not to take any coercive action against them until further orders.
Senior counsel Mahesh Jethmalani, who appeared for AIB and for Ranveer and Arjun, argued that the programme was full of humor and entertained the audience. He also urged the court to grant interim relief to Bollwood stars Ranveer and Arjun, considering that other actors and comedians had already been granted such a relief.
